by Phil Nyden, Loyola University Chicago,
and Gwen Nyden, Oakton Community College
Like many cities, Chicago is a city of contrastsbetween rich and poor, black and white, Latino and Anglo, immigrant and
non-immigrant. But uneven development has been apparent in Chicago for many years. Through the early 1980s, Harvey
Zorbaugh's 1928 classic, The Gold Coast and the Slum, could have been used as a walking tour guide. The contrast between
the Gold Coast mansions just north of the Magnificent Mile (along North Michigan Avenue) and the low-income neighborhood just
six blocks to the west was still present. In 1980, nine of the 15 poorest neighborhoods in the U.S. were in Chicago.
Last year, Chicago was listed as the third most segregated city in the United States (after Gary and Detroit). While other
Northeastern and Midwestern older industrial cities provided tough competition for this highly questionable distinction, Chicago's
long history of housing segregation, local race-based politics, and discriminatory lending practices has left a lasting mark on the
social landscape of the nation's third city.
The symbolism of uneven development even carries through into professional sports. With its distinct
uptown character, Wrigley
Field, home to the Cubs, is
affectionately described as the
"friendly confines." The historic
field in gentrified "Wrigleyville,"
full of popular bars and trendy
restaurants, is a sharp
contrast to the cement
coliseum build on the
Southside for the White Sox.
Comisky Park, rarely described by the
media as being in a
"neighborhood," is across a
12-lane interstate from Taylor
Homes and Stateway Gardens,
two of the greatest
concentrations of public
housing in the United States.
Just to the west of this new
stadium is Bridgeport, the
working class community that
had long been home to Mayor
Richard J. Daley (the "original"
Mayor Daley). A few years ago
Bridgeport was abandoned by
son Mayor Richard M. Daley in
favor of the trendy new Central
Station neighborhood at the
south end of Grant Park. Retail
businesses and other
investments had preceded
Richard M. in the exodus from
Bridgeport, reflecting the
patterns of disinvestment
typical of many former white
ethnic neighborhoods.
There are many other signs of
continued uneven
development. Following the
decline of basic industrial
employment which hit some
Chicago neighborhoods hard
in the late 1970s and early
1980s, Chicago has more
recently been riding an
economic boom. While
investment have found its way
into most neighborhoods, the
trickle of money coming into
some low-income
communities has been
overshadowed by the flood of
money being pumped into
Chicago's central business
district. Similarly, Chicago's
lakefront park system is biased
toward the more white and
more affluent Northside. A
recent Chicago Tribune
series on Chicago's park
system pointed to inequities in
public investment. In addition
to having double the acreage of
the southern lakefront, the
northern lakefront has more
food concession stands,
playgrounds, marinas, and
other amenities. New figures
on Chicago Transit Authority
budget planning indicate that
through 2002, $65 million will
be spent to improve downtown
subway stations while only
$15 million will be spent on all
the other stations in the entire
system.
You will not have to walk very
far from the ASA host hotel to
see the boom in hotel, retail,
and housing investment boom
taking place in the Loop and
North Michigan Avenue area. A
recent Brookings Institution
report projects that 90,000
new residents will move into
the central business district in
the next 10 years. These will
be primarily young and
middle-aged professionals
with typical individual earnings
in excess of $100,000
annually. Along North Michigan
Avenue, a new development
will include more upscale
stores and a multi-story
Disney "urban" theme park
(opening before August 1999)
and other upscale retailers.
The millions of dollars pouring
into new retail and
entertainment development
continues a decades-long
development "winning streak"
for the city's Magnificent Mile.
At the same time, the city is
experiencing an affordable
housing shortage, partially
produced by the dismantling of
concentrated low-income
high-rise public housing built
in the 1950s and 1960s. While
the policy of concentrating the
poor in high rise housing has
been recognized as a policy
failure by liberals and
conservatives alike, the
absence of any clear strategy
to build and preserve
affordable housing in Chicago
has been a major battle line in
city and community politics. A
University of Illinois Chicago
report points to nearly 40,000
affordable housing units lost
in the 1980s alone, with more
than 20,000 units likely to be
lost in the course of
"downsizing" public housing.
However, these and other
uneven development
strategies have not gone
unchallenged in this city noted
for its change-oriented
community activists and
organizations, from Jane
Adams and the settlement
houses, Saul Alinsky and the
Industrial Areas Foundation, to
the scores of community
activists and organizations in
Chicago today. Citywide
groups such as the Chicago
Association of Neighborhood
Development Organizations
(CANDO), the Community
Workshop for Economic
Development, the Chicago
Rehab Network, the Women's
Self-Employment Project,
Neighborhood Capital Budget
Group, and the Woodstock
Institute work with researchers
in documenting successful
alternatives to uneven growth
and serve as advocate and
technical assistance
agencies.
There are numerous
examples of efforts to present
specific alternative models of
uneven growth. The
Leadership Council for
Metropolitan Open Communities, a group
founded after Martin Luther
King's marches to
desegregate Chicago
neighborhoods in the 1960s,
coordinated a national
community-university research
project with Loyola University
Chicago and Chicago State
University to determine what
factors produced stable racial
and ethnic diversity in urban
communities. The U.S.
Department of Housing and
Urban Development just
published this nine-city report,
which includes descriptions of
Chicago's Rogers Park,
Edgewater, and Uptown
neighborhoods, in its journal
Cityscape. In conjunction with
the Organization of the
NorthEast, an umbrella group
of activist community
organizations in Uptown along
Chicago's northern lakefront,
Loyola University researchers
have documented successful
efforts to preserve some of the
ten HUD-subsidized
affordable high-rise apartment
buildings in the face of
gentrification and potential
displacement trends in this
mixed-income neighborhood
In the cultural realm, uneven
development has been
challenged by the successful
Mexican Fine Arts Museum
and planned African-American
Historic southside Bronzeville
District. Opened in 1987, the
Mexican Fine Arts Museum is
one of the most impressive
community-based museums
in the city. From its annual
Dia de Los Muertos (Day of
the Dead) exhibit to shows
featuring contemporary Latino
artists, it has provided
opportunities to display
Mexican and
Mexican-American art not
provided by established arts
institutions. The Bronzeville
Historical District project
hopes to invest in and
preserve the strong
African-American heritage in
Chicago's Mid-Southside.
From planned creation of a
Jazz-Blues Museum to tours
featuring contributions by
Black educators, social
scientists, and journalists, the
District will stress
contributions by
African-Americans often
ignored by major cultural
institutions.
Chicago is often pointed to as
being in the lead of
university-community
partnerships where
academics and community
activists work together in
completing policy and
evaluation research aimed at
documenting and
strengthening grassroots
innovations to pressing urban
problems. The Policy
Research Action Group
(PRAG), a collaborative
network of four universities as
well as more than 25
community-based and
citywide civic organizations,
has just celebrated its tenth
anniversary. Having been
involved in more than 200
collaborative projects on
issues ranging from housing
and employment to the
environment and
transportation, PRAG has
established a national
reputation. Its university
partners include Loyola
University's Center for Urban
Research and Learning,
University of Illinois Chicago's
Center for Urban Economic
Development (and its Great
Cities Program), DePaul
University's Egan Center, and
Chicago State University's
Neighborhood Assistance
Center. If you want to learn
more about this collaborative
network while you are in town,
e-mail us
(pragcomm@luc.edu) or call
(312-915-7760). A tour on
Chicago's "Frontyard and
Backyards" scheduled for the
afternoon of Monday, August 9,
will also address some of the
same issues of uneven
development that we have
discussed here.
|