Corine Donnelly wants to submit for journal publication a paper on
predictors of successful job placement based on her three-month
contract with Backtowork, Inc. She asks representatives of Backtowork,
Inc., for permission to publish the paper. They agree but ask her not
to identify the organization as the source of her support.
Questions
1. Should Donnelly submit the paper without revealing
her source of financial support?
2. If there are exceptions to revealing the source of
financial support of one's work, what principles guide this decision?
Reflect on the above questions and form your
own answers before clicking the Discussion
key to review the commentary provided with this case.
Discussion
Sociologists customarily disclose sources of financial support of their
work in presentations and publications. The purposes of such disclosure
are to acknowledge the generosity of agencies that support research and
to assure that any conflicts of interest, or the appearance of
conflicts of interest, have been considered and have not compromised
professional judgment or created biases in research decisions. Donnelly
should have clarified publication rights and the disclosure of support
with Backtowork, Inc., at the outset in her contract with the company.
If she had known that the company did not want its sponsorship to be
revealed, she could have created checks to reduce the possibility of
bias. Donnelly should inform the journal editor that her work was
funded by a company that prefers to remain anonymous, leaving it to the
journal editor to decide what action is necessary.